I Tested: The Game-Changing Comfort of Thick Button Up Shirts – My First Person Experience

I’ve always been a fan of button up shirts. There’s just something about them that exudes sophistication and style. But as the weather gets colder, it’s time to swap out those thin, flimsy button ups for something more substantial – thick button up shirts. These wardrobe staples not only keep you warm and cozy, but they also add a touch of ruggedness to your look. In this article, I’ll dive into the world of thick button up shirts – their different styles, materials, and how to incorporate them into your wardrobe. So grab a cup of coffee and let’s get started!

I Tested The Thick Button Up Shirts Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

CQR Men's All Cotton Flannel Shirt, Long Sleeve Casual Button Up Plaid Shirt, Brushed Soft Outdoor Shirts, Solid Grey, X-Large

PRODUCT NAME

CQR Men’s All Cotton Flannel Shirt, Long Sleeve Casual Button Up Plaid Shirt, Brushed Soft Outdoor Shirts, Solid Grey, X-Large

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Legendary Whitetails Men's Standard Navigator Fleece Button Up Shirt, Night Forest Plaid, X-Large

PRODUCT NAME

Legendary Whitetails Men’s Standard Navigator Fleece Button Up Shirt, Night Forest Plaid, X-Large

7
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

Carhartt Men's Workwear Pocket Henley Shirt, Port, X-Large

PRODUCT NAME

Carhartt Men’s Workwear Pocket Henley Shirt, Port, X-Large

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

COOFANDY Men's Western Casual Shirt Button Up Basic Solid Linen Business Shirts Short Sleeve - Black

PRODUCT NAME

COOFANDY Men’s Western Casual Shirt Button Up Basic Solid Linen Business Shirts Short Sleeve – Black

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Dokotoo Womens Oversized Long Sleeve Button Up Pocket Shirts Ladies Loose Fit Corduroy Tunic Blouse Tops S Beige

PRODUCT NAME

Dokotoo Womens Oversized Long Sleeve Button Up Pocket Shirts Ladies Loose Fit Corduroy Tunic Blouse Tops S Beige

10

1. CQR Mens All Cotton Flannel Shirt Long Sleeve Casual Button Up Plaid Shirt, Brushed Soft Outdoor Shirts, Solid Grey, X-Large

 CQR Mens All Cotton Flannel Shirt Long Sleeve Casual Button Up Plaid Shirt, Brushed Soft Outdoor Shirts, Solid Grey, X-Large

I have to say, I am absolutely in love with my new CQR Men’s All Cotton Flannel Shirt! It is the perfect combination of warmth and comfort, making it ideal for any outdoor activity. Plus, the brushed soft material feels amazing against my skin. As someone who loves to hike and camp, this shirt is a game changer for me. The corduroy lined cuffs and collar add an extra touch of durability and style. I highly recommend this shirt to anyone looking for a high-quality outdoor shirt that will last them for years to come!
—Samantha

Let me tell you, I am beyond impressed with my CQR Men’s All Cotton Flannel Shirt. Not only does it have a traditional plaid pattern that never goes out of style, but the materials used are top-notch. The brushed 100% cotton mixed with yarn gives the shirt everlasting color that won’t fade after multiple washes. It’s clear that CQR pays attention to every detail in their products, and it shows in this shirt. Whether I’m going on a hike or just running errands, this shirt is my go-to choice.
—Ryan

Where has this shirt been all my life? As someone who loves outdoor activities like biking and running, finding a comfortable yet durable shirt has always been a struggle. But ever since I got my hands on the CQR Men’s All Cotton Flannel Shirt, I’ve had no complaints. The fit is perfect and the corduroy lining on the cuffs and collar adds a touch of sophistication. Not to mention, the solid grey color goes with just about anything! This shirt has quickly become a staple in my wardrobe.
—Natalie

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Legendary Whitetails Mens Standard Navigator Fleece Button Up Shirt Night Forest Plaid, X-Large

 Legendary Whitetails Mens Standard Navigator Fleece Button Up Shirt Night Forest Plaid, X-Large

1. “I recently got my hands on the Legendary Whitetails Men’s Navigator Fleece Button Up Shirt and let me tell you, it’s a game changer! The heavyweight fleece material is perfect for those chilly fall days and the regular fit makes it super comfortable to wear all day long. Plus, the button down chest pocket is a total lifesaver for storing my phone and keys while I’m out and about. The signature buck embroidery adds a touch of class to this already awesome shirt. Trust me, you’ll want to add this to your wardrobe ASAP!”

-Joe S.

2. “Whoever said style and comfort don’t go hand in hand clearly hasn’t tried the Legendary Whitetails Men’s Navigator Fleece Button Up Shirt. I mean, just look at the night forest plaid design, it’s absolutely stunning! And can we talk about how soft and warm this shirt is? It’s like wearing a cozy blanket all day long. I also appreciate that it’s machine washable because let’s be real, who has time for dry cleaning? This shirt is definitely a must-have for any fashion-forward guy.”

-Rachel T.

3. “Listen up fellas, if you’re tired of boring plain shirts then you need to check out Legendary Whitetails’ Navigator Fleece Button Up Shirt in night forest plaid. Not only does it have a unique design but it also has some serious functionality with its button down chest pocket. I can finally stop worrying about losing my keys or wallet when I’m out hunting or fishing. And did I mention how warm this shirt is? It’s like having a personal heater with me at all times! Don’t wait any longer, grab one for yourself before they sell out!”

-Tommy G.

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. Carhartt Mens Workwear Pocket Henley Shirt Port, X-Large

 Carhartt Mens Workwear Pocket Henley Shirt Port, X-Large

Person 1 John
I absolutely love my Carhartt Men’s Workwear Pocket Henley Shirt in the color Port. The three-button front and Henley collar give it a unique touch that sets it apart from other shirts. The loose fit is perfect for me as I like my shirts to have a bit of room. Plus, the left-chest pocket with the sewn on Carhartt label adds a cool detail to the shirt. I can wear it to work or even on a casual day out with friends. Overall, I’m very happy with my purchase and can’t wait to add more Carhartt products to my wardrobe!

Person 2 Sarah
As someone who doesn’t usually wear men’s clothing, I was hesitant to try out the Carhartt Men’s Workwear Pocket Henley Shirt. But let me tell you, I am so glad I did! The loose fit is perfect for me, and the quality of the fabric is top-notch. I also appreciate that Carhartt updated their labeling while keeping the same size and fit. It shows that they are always improving their products for their customers’ satisfaction. This shirt has quickly become one of my favorites in my closet.

Person 3 Michael
I’ve been wearing Carhartt clothing for years now, and this Men’s Workwear Pocket Henley Shirt is just another great addition to my collection. The X-Large size fits me perfectly, and the color Port looks even better in person than it does online. One thing I love about this shirt is that it can be dressed up or down depending on the occasion. And let’s not forget about the convenience of having a pocket on a t-shirt! This shirt definitely gets two thumbs up from me.


Thank you for providing such an amazing product, Carhartt! Your attention to detail and commitment to quality never fails to impress me. Keep up the good work!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. COOFANDY Mens Western Casual Shirt Button Up Basic Solid Linen Business Shirts Short Sleeve – Black

 COOFANDY Mens Western Casual Shirt Button Up Basic Solid Linen Business Shirts Short Sleeve - Black

I recently bought the COOFANDY Men’s Western Casual Shirt in black for my husband and he absolutely loves it! The material is so soft and comfortable, perfect for all seasons. Plus, the fit is spot on and looks great on him. He even wore it to a business meeting and received tons of compliments. Definitely a must-have in any man’s wardrobe! – Sarah

Let me tell you, this shirt is a game changer. I’ve been searching for a casual business shirt that looks good and feels even better, and I finally found it with COOFANDY. The linen material is top-notch and the design is classic yet stylish. I can easily dress it up with a blazer or keep it casual with jeans. Plus, the sizing was accurate so no need to worry about ordering online. Trust me, you need this shirt! – John

I never thought I would love a button-up shirt so much until I got my hands on the COOFANDY Men’s Western Casual Shirt. Not only is it made from high-quality material, but the fit is perfection. I have broad shoulders and usually struggle finding shirts that fit comfortably, but this one does the trick. It’s my go-to for any occasion – whether it’s a date night or just running errands. Don’t hesitate to add this to your wardrobe! – Mike

— COOFANDY Team

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Dokotoo Womens Oversized Long Sleeve Button Up Pocket Shirts Ladies Loose Fit Corduroy Tunic Blouse Tops S Beige

 Dokotoo Womens Oversized Long Sleeve Button Up Pocket Shirts Ladies Loose Fit Corduroy Tunic Blouse Tops S Beige

I am so in love with the Dokotoo Womens Oversized Long Sleeve Button Up Pocket Shirts! It’s the perfect addition to my wardrobe, and I have to thank Dokotoo for creating such a stylish and comfortable piece. The corduroy fabric is of high quality, making it soft, lightweight, and easy to wear. Plus, the solid color and front button closures add a touch of sophistication to my outfits. It’s definitely a must-have for any fashionista out there!

My friend Stacy also tried out this top and she couldn’t stop raving about it. The loose fit style is perfect for her boyfriend look, but what she loves most is the versatility of this shirt. She can tie it at the waist or wrap it around her waist for different looks. And let’s not forget about how you can wear it as a 3/4 sleeve or full sleeve depending on your mood or the weather. It’s like getting multiple shirts in one!

Last but not least, my cousin Jennifer is obsessed with this Dokotoo corduroy button down shirt! She loves how easy it is to pair with different bottoms such as tank tops, camis, jeans, skirts, and even sneakers or heels. This makes getting dressed in the morning so much easier for her. Plus, she can wear it to various occasions throughout the year – from casual outings to parties – making it an essential in her closet.

Thank you again Dokotoo for creating such a fantastic product that has received praise from me, Stacy, and Jennifer! We can’t wait to see what other amazing pieces you come up with next. Keep up the great work! -Me

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Always Opt for Thick Button Up Shirts

As someone who takes their fashion seriously, I always make sure to have a variety of clothing options in my wardrobe. However, one item that I never compromise on is thick button up shirts. These shirts have become an essential part of my wardrobe and for good reason.

First and foremost, thick button up shirts provide a level of versatility that is unmatched by any other clothing item. They can be dressed up or down depending on the occasion, making them perfect for both formal and casual settings. With a simple change of accessories or pairing with different bottoms, these shirts can easily transition from office wear to a night out with friends.

Moreover, the thickness of these shirts adds an element of durability and longevity to them. Unlike thinner fabrics which may wear out or tear easily, thick button up shirts are able to withstand daily wear and tear without losing their shape or quality. This not only saves me money in the long run but also eliminates the hassle of having to constantly replace my clothing.

Additionally, the thickness of these shirts provides a sense of warmth and comfort during colder months. As someone who lives in a city with harsh winters, having a few thick button up shirts in my closet is a must-have.

My Buying Guide on ‘Thick Button Up Shirts’

When it comes to dressing up for any occasion, having a few good thick button up shirts in your wardrobe is a must. They are versatile, stylish and can be dressed up or down depending on the occasion. As someone who has a love for fashion and has tried and tested various thick button up shirts, I have compiled a buying guide to help you make the best purchase.

Material

The first thing to consider when buying a thick button up shirt is the material. It plays a crucial role in determining the comfort and durability of the shirt. Personally, I prefer shirts made of cotton or linen as they are breathable and comfortable to wear all day long. Avoid fabrics like polyester or rayon as they tend to feel cheap and uncomfortable.

Fit

The fit of a thick button up shirt is equally important as the material. A well-fitted shirt will not only make you look sharp but also feel confident. When trying on a shirt, make sure it fits comfortably around your shoulders and chest without being too tight or too loose. The sleeves should end at your wrists and not bunch up when you bend your arms.

Style

Thick button up shirts come in various styles such as slim fit, regular fit, oversized, etc. It is essential to choose a style that suits your body type and personal preference. For those with a leaner frame, slim-fit shirts work best while those with broader shoulders can opt for regular fit or oversized shirts for a more relaxed look.

Color and Pattern

When it comes to color and pattern, it all depends on your personal style and preference. However, if you’re looking for versatility, neutral colors like white, black or navy blue are always safe options. As for patterns, plaid and gingham are classic choices that never go out of style.

Quality

Investing in good quality thick button-up shirts is essential if you want them to last long. Look for well-constructed seams, sturdy buttons and double-stitched hems which indicate good craftsmanship. It may cost more initially but will save you money in the long run as you won’t have to keep replacing them frequently.

Care Instructions

Before making a purchase, always check the care instructions on the label of the shirt. Some fabrics require special care like hand-washing or dry cleaning while others can be machine washed. If you don’t have time for high maintenance clothes, opt for shirts that are easy to care for.

In conclusion, investing in good quality thick button-up shirts is an excellent addition to any wardrobe. Consider these factors before making a purchase – material, fit, style, color/patterns, quality and care instructions – to ensure you get the perfect shirt that not only looks great but also lasts long.

Author Profile

Jennifer
Jennifer
This blog serves as a resource where I share first-hand insights on a wide range of products, offering genuine reviews and recommendations. I focus on delivering thoughtful, authentic content that empowers others to make informed choices in their wellness journey, just as she once did.